THE DISHMASTER

Entertainment News With a Side of Dish

Tuesday

26

February 2013

1

COMMENTS

Should the United States Have Detained Emad Burnat? — Michael Moore is Outraged

Written by , Posted in General

5_Broken_Cameras_Movie_Poster_LargeIf you make a film that is critical of the United States of a United States ally, does it stand to reason that the United States will and should give you extra attention when you enter its country? It’s an intriguing question that folks like Michael Moore seem to think has a definitive answer. Unlike Michael Moore, I believe the line to be squishy.

When Michael Moore’s friend, Palestinian filmmaker Emad Burnat, was detained by immigration officials at the Los Angeles International Airport on his way to attend the Oscars for his film, 5 Broken Cameras, Moore was outraged, and his outrage has caused subsequent controversy after Guardian columnist and blogger Glenn Greenwald called out Buzzfeed reporter Tessa Stuart for inaccurately downplaying what happened. According to Greenwald, Stuart allegedly used a government official as her source, and any such official would obviously be biased.

Now that I’ve summarized the events, allow me to make my point. My issue doesn’t surround the length of Burnat’s detention. It’s whether the United States had the right to take extra precautions. Is it really relevant that the man was invited to the Oscars? If our national security is at issue, then he should be detained. It’s clear Moore felt no such security was at issue, and this was akin to profiling. But is racial profiling okay if it pertains to our safety?

  • AdTerrorum

    There’s a pebble in the shoe of this argument. All these freedoms are given up in the name of safety during air travel. But driving to the airport is 100x more dangerous than flying, and we seem to find a way to keep our Civil Rights during that activity.